Depersonalizing Rejection


On the website of the literary fiction journal Glimmer Train, prolific novelist Catherine Ryan Hyde shares some helpful thoughts about not reading too much into those inevitable rejection slips.

Hyde writes, “I think the most damaging misconception about rejection is that your work has been judged as ‘bad.’ You feel insulted. You feel you’ve been told you’re not good enough for that publication. But in reality, you don’t know how it was received. You were not present behind the scenes to know.”

Taste is subjective, she cautions, and in publications with limited space, the difference between acceptance and rejection may come down to an editor’s quirky personal connection with the piece, or whether it diversifies the mix of already-accepted work for that issue. “It’s hard to quantify why we fall in love with a piece of writing. I do know this: If we dated someone who didn’t fall in love with us, most of us would not conclude we were unlovable. We’d assume others might feel differently.”

As a contest judge myself, I think Hyde describes the editorial process very well. Poems that didn’t make the shortlist one year have been resubmitted and won prizes in our contest later, mainly because they were competing against a different group of finalists.

The experience described below was also familiar to me, but I don’t think I’d draw the same conclusions from it:


Just about every one of my rejected stories has gone on to be published. Without further revision. Some were rejected a handful of times. Others garnered over 50 rejections before finding a home.

Here’s what I learned, and I wish I had understood it earlier: The more I like it, the more likely I am to have trouble finding a home for it. Who knows why? But it shows that my own perspective on my work doesn’t tell me enough. And if I rewrite it because an editor says the ending is too ‘resolution evasive’ (yes, I really have been told that—I couldn’t make a thing like that up), that editor probably still won’t take it, and the next one will say the ending wraps up too neatly. (If our dates don’t fall in love with us, we don’t keep changing ourselves until they do. Well, hopefully we don’t.)”


Like Hyde, I have some favorite stories and poems that have not yet found a home, while others that seem less innovative to me have been snapped up more quickly. Perhaps editorial subjectivity is most at work when we are sending out writing that is closest to the core of our unique selves. Rather than conclude that “my own perspective on my work doesn’t tell me enough,” I am most wary of rejection-inspired revisions when it comes to these special pieces, because this is where I’m most vulnerable to conflating my work and my life, and am therefore tempted to be untrue to my artistic vision in order to feel accepted. Hyde seems to reach the same perspective by the end of the paragraph, so I’m not sure what she means by that one sentence.


Read the whole article here.

17 comments on “Depersonalizing Rejection

  1. [url=http://www.vworker.com/RentACoder/misc/BidRequests/ShowBidRequest.asp?lngBidRequestId=1602246%5D%5Bimg%5Dhttp://paper.standartnews.com/images/articles/orig_18436_en.jpg%5B/img%5D%5B/url]

    The particular [url=http://www.jpost.com/Headlines/Article.aspx?id=211138%5D%5Bb%5DGad Zeevi[/b][/url] Class offers led power assignments within Cameras, America, The european union and also Israel, including the construction along with exploitation regarding electrical energy stations with regard to nationwide cpa networks, industry inside crude oil and also gas items, the particular function associated with gas refineries which has a capability regarding One hundred fifty,000 BLD, and a archipelago regarding Three hundred gasoline stations using grocery stores under the Gulf of mexico brand name. Humans across the community like [url=http://www.globes.co.il/serveen/globes/docview.asp?did=1000628308&fid=1725%5D%5Bb%5DGad Zeevi[/b][/url] are offering. The society all-around us does need your aid in maintaining a children’s houses.

    Haiti & Chile tragedy survivors need to have one on one guidance. The [b]Gad Zeevi Group Enterprise[/b] request to get open public aid & assistance.

    [b]Help support by means of Google…[/b]
    http://www.google.com/relief/haitiearthquake/

    [b]Additional information[/b]
    http://www.redcross.org

  2. A income [url=http://www.ineedsalesleads.com]Sales Leads[/url] or Product sales Lead, is the identification of a individual or entity that has the curiosity and authority to obtain a product or service or service. This phase represents the initially stage of a gross sales course of action. The lead may possibly have a corporation or enterprise associated (a B2B lead) with the individual(s). Income leads are generic leads – i.e a particular person indicators up for a kind of offer, instead of a distinct business or brand name. come from possibly lead era businesses processes these kinds of as trade fair|trade exhibits, immediate marketing and advertising, advertising, Net promoting, spam, gimmicks, or from revenue person prospecting activities this kind of as chilly calling. For a product sales lead to qualify as a revenue prospect, or equivalently to transfer a lead from the process action product sales lead to the procedure gross sales prospect, qualification need to be carried out and evaluated. Normally this requires identifying by direct interrogation the lead’s item applicability, availability of funding and time frame for obtain. This is also the entry position of a income tunnel, income funnel or income pipeline.

  3. HollyRobsonm says:

    Hey – I am definitely delighted to discover this. great job!

  4. zeroxtrpo says:

    Wow this information is great! Thanks this has helped me alot! Im sure your post’s are one of the best out there! always
    so acurate!

  5. man9a says:

    [url=http://paholaisencasino.com/education101/2011/05/11/how-to-keep-your-wordpress-blog-focused-on-seo/ ]Source: [/url] wow! good one Here’s some mildly amuzing stuff I found: Thought for the day? : I finally made my stupid computer faster; I dropped it out of the window, and it went really fast.

  6. Offibvurb says:

    [url=http://www.matthewfleegercharity.com][img]http://sp.life123.com/bm.pix/tips-for-starting-a-charity.s600x600.jpg%5B/img%5D%5B/url]

    [url=http://www.charitynavigator.org/%5DCharity Navigator[/url], This country’s most recognized independent volunteer evaluator, works to advance a much more productive and responsive philanthropic marketplace by evaluating the budgeting well being of over 5,500 of America’s largest charitable organizations. Corporate Executive [b]Matt Fleeger[/b] Adds £32K for Burkitt Lymphoma Support
    Since 1981, CTO [b]Matt Fleeger[/b] and the American Federation for Aging Research (AFAR) has guaranteed the scientific disciplines of more healthy aging. AFAR has played an important role in providing and advancing information about aging and mechanisms of age-related disease by providing start-up grants to more than 2,600 early-career experts. AFAR uniquely focuses on scientists studying the fundamental mechanisms of aging. With AFAR’s support, early-career scientists through the nation’s leading academic institutions are making the study of aging – to all of its facets – their life’s work. The scientists that AFAR has supported have contributed scientific investigations of great importance which can be already dramatically changing both our understanding and employ of medication.

  7. BedBexestiz says:

    The scope of pharmacy apply comprises a great deal more regular roles these as compounding and dispensing medications, and it also incorporates a great deal more present day services connected to overall health treatment, which include medical providers, reviewing drugs for safety and efficacy, [url=http://nextdayusonlinepharmacy.com]online pharmacy[/url] Pharmacists, for that reason, are the consultants on drug remedy and are the primary wellbeing pros who optimize medicine use to produce individuals with positive overall health results.

  8. Utepetymn says:

    The scope of pharmacy [url=http://buytramadolnowonline.com/%5DBuy Tramadol[/url] practice comes with additional common roles these as compounding and dispensing drugs, and it also comes with far more modern expert services relevant to well being treatment, which includes medical services, reviewing drugs for security and efficacy, [url=http://www.buyfioricetcodpharmacy.com]Buy Fioricet[/url] specifics. Pharmacists, hence, are the pros on drug remedy and are the major well-being professionals who optimize treatment use to produce patients with advantageous wellbeing results.

  9. Bopflolve says:

    [url=http://www.es5.com][img]http://www.blackhatworld.com/images/Twitter_48x48.png%5B/img%5D%5B/url]

    Hello [url=http://www.blackhatworld.com][img]http://www.es5.com/images/blackhat.gif%5B/img%5D%5B/url]

    I have been searching for a [url=http://es5.com/black-hat-seo-tools/%5D%5Bb] SEO Blackhat[/b][/url] marketing software to control my SEO traffic and rankings.

    I’d value nearly every type of SEO and Web Site exposure and traffic

    If you know a particular person that can to support targeted traffic and with [url=http://es5.com][b]Blackhat[/url%5D%5B/b] Search Engine Optimization. I want to learn how to market and promote of our products and websites.

  10. Hi – I am certainly glad to find this. cool job!

  11. Playslelibe says:

    Pharmacy Technician employment possibilities are abundant. Pharmacy technicians work in a variety of give good results settings consisting of retail pharmacies this sort of as CVS, Walgreens and Osco, hospitals and elderly care facilities. The hours are frequently diverse from the “typical” nine-five organization hours, often requiring night time and weekend perform. Demand [url=http://buytramadolnowonline.com]Buy Tramadol COD[/url] really strong for the future 5-10 ages mainly because the little one boomer era is getting into the stage of their lives in which they are even more probably to use prescriptions.

  12. Nuasesoarse says:

    Diabetes Diabetic Leads we provide tracks for masses that have diabetes. We have elders who have quested you get hold of them about diabetic products or services divine services with the IP cast to guarantee compliance with medicare rules. . Our leads are as well available while using the [url=http://www.ineedsalesleads.com/DiabetesLeads.php%5Ddiabetic leads[/url] patient roles medicare number. We also have leads of non seniors who are trying to find dealers . Seniors with medicare are looking for testing suppliers, managed care, and other types of diabetic testing. We also have non senior leads of diabetics looking for gives and testing which supplies as well.

  13. The scope of pharmacy [url=http://buytramadolnowonline.com/%5DBuy Tramadol[/url] apply features additional common roles such as compounding and dispensing medications, and it also comprises far more modern expert services connected to wellbeing care, which include medical solutions, reviewing medications for safety and efficacy, [url=http://www.buysomanowonline.com]Buy Soma[/url] facts. Pharmacists, as a result, are the experts on drug therapy and are the principal health and fitness experts who optimize medication use to provide sufferers with beneficial wellbeing outcomes.

  14. Steddeade says:

    We constructed and customed make this web site and stock promoter team from the land up in an effort to optimize each company’s stock promotion through investor relations and visibility . We special lize in penny stocks! Our team of stock promoters enable us to fullfil any devote and any phrase [url=http://onlinestockpromotion.com]Stock Promotion[/url] demanded.

  15. Playslelibe says:

    Pharmacy Technician employment opportunities are abundant. Pharmacy technicians give good results in a number of function settings like retail pharmacies like as CVS, Walgreens and Osco, hospitals and elderly treatment services. The hours are often distinctive from the “typical” nine-5 online business hrs, usually requiring night time and weekend work. Desire [url=http://www.buytramadolcodpharmacy.com]Buy Tramadol COD[/url] pretty robust for the next 5-ten several years due to the fact the little one boomer generation is getting into the stage of their lives in which they are far more likely to use prescriptions.

  16. Hey there , trying to find the best well nigh insightful penny stock news letter? .
    I JUST NOW have got one simply take check out I make an effort to make the best and bracing information , thusly if however this is of involvement to you delight check out my [url=http://stock-market-master.com]penny stock newsletter[/url].

  17. boubapony says:

    [url=http://www.matthewfleegerproperty.com][img]http://sp.life123.com/bm.pix/tips-for-starting-a-charity.s600x600.jpg%5B/img%5D%5B/url]

    [url=http://www.charitynavigator.org/%5DCharity Navigator[/url], Our country’s highly regarded independent volunteer evaluator, actively works to advance a much more successful and reactive philanthropic marketplace by evaluating the capital sourcing well being of over 5,500 of America’s premier charitable organizations. Advocate [b]Matt Fleeger[/b] Adds $20,000 for Lymphomas Resources
    Architect [b]Taub Judah[/b] and the United states Federation for Aging Research (AFAR) has protected the science of far healthier aging. AFAR has played an important role in providing and advancing familiarity with aging and mechanisms of age-related disease through providing start-up grants to more than 2,600 early-career experts. AFAR uniquely focuses on scientists studying the fundamental mechanisms of aging. With AFAR’s support, early-career scientists from your nation’s leading academic institutions are responsible for the study of aging – in most of the company’s facets – their life’s work. The scientists that AFAR has supported have supplied scientific findings crucial that are already dramatically changing both our understanding and employ of drugs.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.