Ten Years After 9/11: Poetry and Some Thoughts

This weekend marks the tenth anniversary of the September 11 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.

Back then, our family was still living on the Lower East Side of Manhattan. At 9 AM, I came upstairs to my office at a publishing company in the West 30s to find everyone peering out the window at smoke billowing from the WTC. We could only see the top floors in the distance so we were not sure what had happened. We saw the flash that was the second plane hitting, but only found out later what had caused it. After that, the grey cloud of smoke and ash was all we could see. Shortly thereafter we learned from the radio that the towers had collapsed and another plane hit the Pentagon. It was then that I became really scared: this was not an accident, it was an attack, and anything could happen now. I don’t remember how we evacuated from the 21st floor, but I assume we must have taken the stairs. Fortunately my husband worked in midtown too and I could email him to come meet me, since the phones were not working.

We walked about three miles downtown to our apartment, part of a stunned crowd. The funereal silence and slowness of these typically high-adrenalin New Yorkers really brought home to us that our world had changed. (I am so proud of the residents of my birth city for not panicking and responding with such courage.) My moms lived across the street from us so we went up to their place to let them know we were all right. One of them was there and the other was making her way downtown from West 96th St., driving her co-workers home, as far as the emergency personnel would allow cars to go. Like everyone that day, we obsessively watched the televised footage of the disaster, hoping for information that would make sense of it all, although it was clear that only speculation and tragedy were on offer.

We were spared the pain that thousands of our fellow New Yorkers endured, in that we did not know anyone who was in those buildings. Our upstairs neighbor lost his brother, Robert Foti, a firefighter. We went to his funeral a few weeks later. Rest in peace, Robert. I will never forget his mother’s words when we paid her a condolence call. “They’ll never find their bodies,” she said, wiping her hand along the table. “See this dust? We’re breathing them in right now.”

What I remember most from those early days was the fear of what might be demanded of us. What sacrifices would we have to make? Would it be like World War II, when the homefront was part of the battle? I was worried that Adam would feel a sense of duty to enlist. Though I am the least bureaucratic person in the world and had just escaped from my legal career, I sent away for a pamphlet about joining the Judge Advocate General’s Corps.

Our preoccupations of the week before were tinged with tragic irony. Walking home from dinner, in a rush to watch the U.S. Open, Adam and I got sidetracked into an argument about his wish for children. Newly independent of my parents, I was afraid I wouldn’t get to experience life and make progress in my writing career before being submerged in someone else’s needs. After 9/11, I felt keenly the truth that “no one knows the day nor the hour”. Plans are uncertain; family matters most in a crisis. (Double irony since we still haven’t been able to make this happen…)

There was something beautiful about the mindfulness and tenderness with which New Yorkers went about their business in the following weeks. On a crowded midtown bus at rush hour, truly one of the more unpleasant aspects of New York life, I noticed that people gave way to one another instead of jostling and taking offense. We were suddenly grateful that each person next to us was still alive.

And simultaneously there was the crassness of the “Fight Back New York: Go Shopping!” campaign, the alarming speed with which the sidewalk vendors cranked out death-to-Osama T-shirts and flag-festooned junk. The mutual contempt of the pro- and anti-war camps, everyone desperate for a simple narrative, as if death always came to people with a reason and a forewarning, visible if we looked hard enough.

It was supposed to be the end of irony. Even if that had been true, I don’t think it would be a good idea. We need all possible interpretive tools to make our way in a world where 9/11’s happen. What it was, instead, was a collective moment of appreciation that life is precious and mysterious, and that no one is really a stranger. That consciousness was too painful, though, and too unprofitable, to keep up for long. “Go, go, go, said the bird; humankind/Cannot bear very much reality.”

But for that little while, we cried at baseball games, we wore our flag lapel pins and bootleg NYPD and FDNY caps, we prayed over the names in the newspaper and asked forgiveness for being unable to read one more obituary, and we wrote poetry about crashing planes and falling towers and heroes.

Adam and I had just started Winning Writers that summer, and we were putting together the rules for our first annual contest. Distressed by the simplistic verses being written by both the blame-America liberals and the kill-the-Muslims conservatives, we decided that our contest should solicit high-quality and nuanced poetry about war. (2011 will be this topic’s tenth and final year, to be replaced by the Sports Poetry Contest.)

These poems from Israeli author Atar Hadari, honorable mention winner in our 2003 contest, best express how New York felt to me in the aftermath. The “two lights” are the memorial Tribute in Light that represented the lost towers with spotlight beams.

Read more 9/11 reminiscences at the WNET-Channel 13 public television website.


by Atar Hadari

This is the season people die here,
she said, Death comes for them now.
Sometime between the end of winter
and the rains, the rains of summer.

And the funerals followed that summer
like social engagements, a ball, then another ball
one by one, like debutantes
uncles and cousins were presented to the great hall

and bowed and went up to tender
their family credentials to the monarch
who smiled and opened the great doors
and threw their engraved invitations onto the ice

and dancing they threw their grey cufflinks
across each others’ shoulders, they crossed the floor
and circles on circles of Horas
filled the sky silently with clouds, that chilled the flowers.

And funeral trains got much shorter
and people chose to which they went
and into the earth the flowers
went and no one remembered their names

only that they died that summer
when rains came late and the streets emptied
and flags flying on car roof tops
waved like women welcoming the army
into a small, abandoned city.

by Atar Hadari

Two lights were fixed over the town
high up, higher than any star had business being
and yet they shone, not like helicopter beams,
like flames, like something burning and not being consumed.

I stepped two steps toward the fence
to see, to try to see, the fire –
they stayed two gold balls in the sky
and I trod on some stones and smelled dog piles.

Whenever I tried to hear roar
of propellers’ wings, the milk trucks
would careen by in their floats
and commuters late home whizzed by in droves
like ice cream vendors.

Eventually one went out
then the other and suddenly
way above them both
another lit, preternaturally still,
an emptying cinema’s white bulb.

A jogger came out of the dark
my side of the fence
I waved, “Do you know what that is?”
“It’s light to find the terrorists,” he said

and ran and I walked away
looking thru at darkness
and left one bulb in the middle
of the empty cinema

like traces of a flame
after you’ve closed your hand
and clenched your lids
and walked out of the shot

and lights still burn in that sky
and I translate the word of God
out of Hebrew. And wanderers in that dark
mistake those lights for guides through the ruins.

8 comments on “Ten Years After 9/11: Poetry and Some Thoughts

  1. Appropos my online friend Jendi’s posted Memorial regarding the hate-fuelled “9/11” terror attack and the “full alert” and devastating response which was deemed “necessary”:

    I too have posted a blog on this topic, and called it “Ground Zero”. You can view it at ” http://www.nigeriavillagesquare.com/forum/blogs/a-piper-too/ground-zero-11th-september-2011-ten-years-1712 “.

    It has to do also with the value of “prayer” and the necessity of “good thought, good words, and good deeds”, if we want to follow the direction our “Good God” points us to, through the “Good God” words of many modern writers.

    Muslim or Christian (etc), religious (good) lives must be lived “forwards” and not backwards. The word “live” spelled backwards amply demonstrates the lesson: if we live our lives facing the wrong way, we become “evil”.

    No two ways about it.

    Lest we forget !

  2. nop986 says:

    A popular ongoing way to connect individual head of hair extensions is through the show in hair extensions. Personal hair extensions are attached to the clip of discrete,Tip For Handling Women’s Hair thinning, nonetheless sturdy. Cropping real hair extensions hair is easy and quick current to do. Any person can discover to carry it out, creating is likely to be one of the most practical method for just about allClip in hair exts individual has a versatility and comfort than other methods installation individual hair extensions never. They have no access to occupation of the times or the months before the need to be replaced. His or her very character clip means that the user can disengage before going to bed . Then in the morning genuine hair extensions can be reduced to the location on the theme of your minutes.real hair extension cables is an easy and natural all the way to add thickness and the volume of a mind that has all of the natural hair thinning. Unlike a wig or hair part that can usually be easily diagnosed,where to get cheap hair extensions, all individual natural hair extensions, if applied correctly, are indistinguishable from hair these days.human hair extensions are categorized according to their quality. even though there may be variations, the classification is usually grade A by D grade hair exts genuine classified as type A is the highest quality, supplying a complete all natural search as well as feel. This classification contains the hair follicles, even now in place. The genuine hair extensions are available to make certain that all point in the hair follicles same direction, mimicking dynamics.human hair extensions are rank A are clearly the single most expensive. However, with quality A real hair extensions which are can expect better results, and some people even suspected for being placed on a hair file format. Grade B Individual hair extensions are also very good, but not always have the hair attached still.If hair extensions are usually genuine degree C in addition to D grade, then do not possess the silky, smooth and free of tangles excellent top grades. We are not looking much more like a natural,clip in human hair extensions cheap, although not specifically out of place either. Extensions real hair of the lower grades truly must be cheaper to buy.grade Western Remi or Remy, is generally believed that the perfect since the qualified individual curly hair extensions you can get. is likely that the root ends and the follicle directionally aligned with the support keep clear of the intricacies involving hair. The hair is involving European origin, unlike Indian or Asian origin. This means that they are likely to be added directly meet the user’s curren

  3. fgh533 says:


    When I originally commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the same comment Canada Goose Men’s Down Glove. Is there any way you can remove me from that service Canada Goose parkas  ? Thanks! Canada Goose Expedition Parka 

  4. opq594 says:

    Hunt for the Cheapest Monster Outlet Store

    Recording studio headsets apply breathable foam around the ear cups. With very hot summer, nevertheless, individuals will obviously come to feel oppressed from the heating and also work. All of us advise that individuals have on Studio out Best Sennheiser Headphones

    there if it’s a bit trendy. Regardless how spectacular your Facilities physical appearance is actually and how exceptional it is skillfulness and components are usually, there may be nevertheless the bonus ( space ) the load connected with Facilities.


    Today, more and more people choose monster beats while they are there on the road, Cheap Monster Beats the Monster headphones for travel and easily compatible. These headphones could be packed into a small box and all the other places sennheiser headphones best buy could be taken lightly. Here you can the right kind of headphones to get the perfect musical experience. With these headphones, you can understand the true feelings of the artist, shaping the music. Monster headphones you can hear the authentic music during playback to help.


    Monster Beats Solo HD Headphones outlet store, Monster Headphones, free shipping, save off Monster Beats Solo HD Bose Headpones Beats Solo With Control Talk Monster Beats Solo Hd and replica dre beats the Most Popular Beats by dre Graphite Styles. Welcome to buy Monster Beats for sale with free shipping off cheap monster beats by dre solo hd headphones White with control talk clearance on sale, clearance monster beats by dre headphones online for sale, Monster Beats Solo HD all cheap Monster Beats Solo HD are with top quality but low price. Welcome to our beats by dr d to choose dr dre beats.



    Monster Beats headphones today are not just a modern means for listening to high quality music, but also serve as an ideal fashion tool for communicate with others via your cellophane. Will the information so far, you may be wondering where you can get to buy these exclusive designer headphones. And even if you can find where to buy from, can you really afford these headphones? Well, if you can manage to get your exclusive pair of Monster Beats headphones, even at a higher price, you will feel a terrific level of satisfaction by using these exclusive Monster Beats headphones. These kinds of Monster Beats headphones would help you to stay cheerful in your daily routine life and will serve as a great tool for personal communication.


    Monster Beats have a high-quality headphones, it’s reason why many music fans are willing to cost a high price to buy it. The headset is a Grammy-winning artists beats by dre wireless and magic sound audio expert team to research and monster beats by dre

    development. “Monster” in 2008 with the Grammy award-winning artists Dr.Dre and magic sound of audio experts, joint research and development team, the first big headphones Studio

  5. nop805 says:

    £256.12  £117.93,dre beats outlet
    Save: 54% off
    Beats By Dr.Dre Studio Diamond Headphones Limited Edition -Red£242.64  £117.93
    Save: 51% off
    Cheap Beats By Dr.Dre Studio Limited Edition Headphones – Blue£134.79  £83.55
    Save: 38% off
    JustBeats Solo Purple Headphones On-ear with ControlTalk£107.82  £57.91
    Save: 46% off
    Monster Diddybeats Headphones High Performance In-Ear – Pink £303.31  £117.93
    Save: 61% off £235.90  £117.93
    Save: 50% off Beats By Dr.Dre Solo hd Headphones –
    Graphite £155.01  £83.55
    Save: 46% off £253.43  £111.19
    Save: 56% off £134.79  £83.55
    Save: 38% off £242.64  £111.19
    Save: 54% off £242.64  £117.93
    Save: 51% off £256.12  £111.19
    Save: 57% off £256.12  £117.93
    Save: 54% off £155.01  £77.49
    Save: 50% off

  6. hij372 says:

    1301 Internationale Parkway,Paul Smith Sunglasses
    Woodridge, IL 60517-4956

    Paul Stuart’s Public Records and Other Information

    Click to see more on

  7. rst352 says:

    mercredi 16 mai 2007
     Marvel Henry

    Although the official language of Trinidad & Tobago is English, there exists within the population a group of people who speak Kwèyòl. This language has had a profound effect on the speech patterns of all Trinidadians from the moment it emerged on the island to the present time. To most people who do not speak the language, it is known simply as a “Patois” most people are of the view that Kwèyòl is not a legitimate language and simply a vernacular of the French language, it is also a sad fact that most Trinidadians do not realize that Kwèyòl is an increate part of their culture. Trinidad was discovered by Christopher Columbus in 1498 during this third voyage to the new world, it was reported that he landed on the southern coast of the island near present-day Moruga,usweddingdresse, when he landed he saw three hills and named the island “La Trinidad” meaning “The Trinity” ; true colonization of the island by the Spanish began by 1507 and it remained a Spanish colony until it was captured for the British in 1797 by Sir Ralph Abercrombie, the island was officially ceded to the British in 1802 by the Treaty of Amiens. It was during the Spanish colonial occupation, that the Kwèyòl language as spoken in Trinidad was born.

    History tells us that even though the Spanish kept the island for three hundred years unchallenged, they, for various reasons were not able to develop the island along the usual patterns of European colonial occupation, and as such, Trinidad remained the most undeveloped colony in the Caribbean ; there are many reports by people who visited the island under Spanish rule. Many of these reports tell of native Indians running wild doing as they pleased and also of the very poor and almost nonexistent infrastructure ; the problem in Trinidad was dire indeed, so much so that by the late 18th century Trinidad’s population was about two to three thousand, comprising of some Spaniards the remainder of the native population that survived the Spanish incursion and a few Africans who were imported to work on the plantations. Trinidad was a colony ripe for take-over by another European power ; the Spanish realizing this, proclaimed the “cédula de población” which invited any catholic subject on good terms with the Spanish crown, to settle in Trinidad on the condition that they swore absolute loyalty to the Spanish and obeyed the Spanish laws for governing the colony ; this proclamation was procured by Philippe-Rose Roume de Saint-Laurent. The Spanish also gave many incentives to lure settlers to the island, including exemption from taxes for ten years and grants of land to set up plantations.

    It was reasoned that settlers from the more populous French islands should be gi

  8. def209 says:

    mnova.eu Home ,tod’s red suede women’s tod’s lace moccasins,burberry belt replica,gucci shoes for me,cheap gucci slippers

    Direct Download! up to 10X FASTER » (View Demonstration)

    Eminem 2012 Pre-Release Leaked Beats – might also be available on usenet.

    Download via torrent,beats by dre custom,custom beats by dre! or use » (Magnet – DHT – Usenet)

    *FREE* Direct Download – Eminem 2012 Pre-Release Leaked Beats.torrent

    Category: Music » Other
    Health:  42 seeds,dre beats outlet,Tod’s Buckle Ankle Boots 2011, 0 peers
    Updated: 1 month ago —  (Update Now)
    Added: 1 month ago — []


    Total size: 81.56 MB
    Pieces: 4 x 64 KB
    Hash: aa3f8da3af573a7cc673cbb7a6c2c95875462e84
    Tracker: udp://tracker.publicbt.com:80/announce
    Rapidshare: This file may be available on rapidshare.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.